A page edited by everyone ends up saying only what nobody objected to. Give each page a written purpose, one writer and one reviewer, and send colleagues' extra paragraphs to pages where they belong.

Every line approved, nothing said

The services page went to four people for comments. It came back with four sets of changes, and all of them were accepted, because each one seemed reasonable.

One partner softened the reply time. Another added a paragraph about a specialty. The operations manager added two disclaimers, and somebody replaced a plain sentence with a phrase about tailored solutions.

The page that went live offended nobody. It also told a visitor almost nothing they could not have guessed before they arrived.

Pages written by committee rarely look broken. They look like every other page in the trade, which is exactly the problem.

What the edits do to a page

The second is the one that costs the most. A specific promise is often the only sentence a reader remembers, and it is the first thing a nervous reviewer removes.

Why every change seemed reasonable

Reviewers read a draft for risk to themselves: whether a client could hold them to a line, whether their own department is missing, whether a claim sounds too bold.

Nobody reads it for the visitor, because nobody was asked to. Removing a specific line feels safe and adding a paragraph feels helpful, so pages only ever get vaguer and longer.

Which is how a page ends up shaped by every concern in the building except the reader's.

Write down what the page is for

Before anybody writes or edits, put one sentence at the top of the draft: who the page is for, what they need to learn, and what they should do next.

For a renovation company's basement page, something like: homeowners comparing three companies, who need to know what the company handles and roughly how long it takes, and should book a visit.

That sentence is the test for every edit that follows. A change that helps that reader stays. A change that serves somebody else goes somewhere else.

It also settles arguments without anybody losing face, since the question becomes what the page is for rather than whose paragraph matters more.

One person holds the pen

One person writes the page from start to finish: a member of staff, the owner, or a writer brought in for the job.

Colleagues supply facts, not wording. The site supervisor explains how long a basement takes from demolition to paint; the writer decides where that belongs and how to say it.

A single writer gives the page a single voice. Six people's sentences stitched together read like six people, and visitors notice the seams even when they cannot say why.

Facts and wording are different reviews

Splitting the review in two is what keeps a page intact.

Anyone whose area the page touches checks the facts in it: prices, timings, what is and is not included. Those corrections are always accepted, because they are about accuracy.

One person, usually the owner or a managing partner, decides on wording. Everybody else's views on tone go to that person, who weighs them against the purpose sentence.

Give the fact check a deadline of a few days. A draft left circulating for a month keeps collecting edits.

A worked example

An independent insurance brokerage with three offices, each run by a partner, rewrote its business insurance page last year.

The draft went to all three partners and the compliance manager. Every change was accepted, and the page grew to well over a thousand words.

Its first sentence now promised comprehensive, tailored coverage from trusted insurers. Comparing quotes from several insurers had become access to a wide range of markets.

The Saturday hours had gone, because one office closes on Saturdays.

This spring the managing partner wrote a purpose sentence: owners of small businesses buying or renewing commercial insurance, who need to know what is covered and how a quote works.

The office manager rewrote the page against it. Each partner checked only the facts for their own line of business, and the paragraphs on contractors and restaurants became pages of their own.

The disclaimers became one line linking to the full terms, which compliance approved. The Saturday hours came back, with the office that keeps them named.

The colleague with a paragraph to add

Somebody always has one: a service they are proud of, a credential, a story from a memorable job.

Ask which question the paragraph answers for the reader named in the purpose sentence. If it answers one, it goes in, often in place of something weaker.

If it does not, offer it a home instead of a refusal: its own page, the about page, a project story or a blog post. Most colleagues want the paragraph published, not necessarily published here.

And when something goes in, something comes out. A page that only grows becomes the committee draft again within a year.

Keep the specific lines

The sentences committees cut are the ones visitors use: a reply time, a price range, the areas served, how long a warranty lasts.

When a reviewer objects to one, rewrite it to be true rather than vague.

A promise of replies within one business day, two during the spring rush, survives a careful partner. Promptly survives everyone and tells a visitor nothing.

A useful test: if a competitor could publish the sentence unchanged, it is not saying anything about your business.

The counter-case

Some pages genuinely need several reviewers.

Regulated professions may need every claim checked by whoever is responsible for compliance, and a page about safety, guarantees or legal terms should be read by somebody who knows the rules.

And a sole owner has no committee, though an owner editing alone late at night can hedge a page just as thoroughly.

Either way, the page still needs a purpose sentence, one writer and one person who decides.

For the next page

  1. Write the purpose sentence before the draft.
  2. Name one writer for the whole page.
  3. Ask colleagues for facts, not wording.
  4. Name one person who approves the wording.
  5. Set a deadline for the fact check.
  6. Find a home for every extra paragraph.
  7. Read it aloud before it goes live.

Step four is the one that holds the rest together. Without one person entitled to say no, every reasonable request is accepted, and the page drifts back towards saying nothing.

Once the words are settled, laying them out is covered in writing pages in blocks.

Frequently asked questions

Why do pages edited by many people go vague?

Because each reviewer reads for risk to themselves, not for the visitor. Removing a specific line feels safe and adding a paragraph feels helpful, so pages grow vaguer and longer.

What is a purpose sentence?

One sentence at the top of the draft saying who the page is for, what they need to learn and what they should do next. Every edit is tested against it.

Who should write the page?

One person, from start to finish, whether a member of staff, the owner or a hired writer. Colleagues supply facts, and the writer decides where they go and how to say them.

How should colleagues review a draft?

By checking the facts in their own area, such as prices, timings and what is included, within a few days. Decisions about wording rest with one person.

What if a colleague wants to add a paragraph?

Ask which question it answers for the page's reader. If none, give it a home elsewhere, such as its own page or a post, rather than refusing it outright.

How do I keep a specific promise through review?

Rewrite it to be true rather than vague, adding the condition that worried the reviewer. A reply time with a seasonal exception says far more than promptly.

West Coast Media Solutions Inc. provides web design, web development, hosting, digital marketing, and business consulting to organisations across Canada, drawing on more than twenty-five years in the field.

A page every partner has edited?

Send us the page. We will write its purpose sentence, rewrite it for that reader, and show what the edits removed.

Start a Conversation